Hate and the ''Jewish Science'': Anti-Semitism, Nazism, and by S. Frosh

By S. Frosh

Psychoanalysis has consistently grappled with its Jewish origins, occasionally celebrating them and infrequently attempting to get away or deny them. via exploration of Freud's Jewish identification, the destiny of psychoanalysis in Germany lower than the Nazis, and psychoanalytic theories of anti-Semitism, this booklet examines the importance of the Jewish reference to psychoanalysis and what that may let us know approximately political and mental resistance, anti-Semitism and racism.

Show description

Read Online or Download Hate and the ''Jewish Science'': Anti-Semitism, Nazism, and Psychoanalysis PDF

Similar judaism books

Einstein's Jewish Science: Physics at the Intersection of Politics and Religion

Is relativity Jewish? The Nazis denigrated Albert Einstein’s innovative concept via calling it "Jewish science," a cost average of the ideological excesses of Hitler and his fans. thinker of technological know-how Steven Gimbel explores the numerous meanings of this provocative word and considers even if there's any feel within which Einstein’s conception of relativity is Jewish.

The Classic Jewish Philosophers: From Saadia Through the Renaissance

This booklet presents a customary reference of the key medieval Jewish philosophers, in addition to an eminently readable narrative of the process medieval Jewish philosophical idea, provided as a reaction to the spiritual-intellectual demanding situations.

Michael and Christ: Michael Traditions and Angel Christology in Early Christianity

This booklet engages the present debate over "angelomorphic Christology. " the writer indicates that mare than one type of angel or angelomorphic Christology used to be present in early Christianity and that Michael traditions specifically supplied a conceptual framework within which Christ's heavenly importance was once understood.

Faith, Reason, and Politics: Essays on the History of Jewish Thought

The earlier decade has witnessed renewed curiosity within the faith-reason debate. yet all too usually the controversy is handled in commonplace phrases, with out being attentive both to adjustments among non secular traditions or to the historic improvement of those traditions. Judaism, with its emphasis on non secular legislation, yields insights into the political ramifications of the matter that fluctuate significantly from Christian ways.

Extra resources for Hate and the ''Jewish Science'': Anti-Semitism, Nazism, and Psychoanalysis

Example text

Even Peter Gay (1988), resistant to special pleading, goes along with Freud’s claim that his status as a ‘marginal man’ might have given him an intellectual advantage. Discussing some other creative critical analysts, for example Darwin, Gay is not convinced of the specificity of Freud’s suggestion of an inherent link between Jewish marginality and the creation of psychoanalysis, but he nevertheless concedes Freud’s point in part. While it does not follow that only a marginal man – in particular, a marginal Jew – could have done Freud’s lifework, the precarious status of Jews in Austrian society did probably underlie the notorious fact that nearly all the first psychoanalysts in Vienna were Jewish.

At the beginning, famously, Freud sets this context of anxiety as relating to the Jewish people and his possible betrayal of them in a time of trouble; significantly, he does not hesitate to remind the reader of his own membership of this disparaged group. To deprive a people of a man whom they take pride in as the greatest of their sons is not a thing to be gladly or carelessly undertaken, least of all by someone who is himself one of them. (Freud, 1939, p. 7) Freud’s defence of his actions, as ever, is in the name of scientific truth, reflecting his deep-rooted if increasingly pessimistic belief that the only viable route to human progress is through the dispelling of illusions and the exercise of rationality.

Categorised as a member of a primitive race, Freud repudiated primitivity, locating himself and his work within European civilisation, with both its scientific and colonising enterprises, and replacing the opposition of Aryan/Jew with the opposition of civilised/primitive. (p. 167) Taken together with Gilman’s analysis, this suggests that Freud responded to anti-Semitism by producing in psychoanalysis a theory that reconstructed human subjectivity according to the image of the disparaged Jew (we are all circumcised/ castrated now); but in so doing 42 Hate and the ‘Jewish Science’ he also preserved the dynamics of racialised discourse, displacing it into his theorising on the ‘dark continent’ of femininity, and embedding in the idea of the ‘primitive’ – itself a powerful motif in nineteenth century western thought – the seeds for much of psychoanalysis’ later racial blindness.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.38 of 5 – based on 14 votes