Controversies in Second Language Writing: Dilemmas and by Christine Pearson Casanave

By Christine Pearson Casanave

Controversies in moment Language Writing isn't really a how-to publication, yet person who makes a speciality of how lecturers in L2 writing should be helped to make reasoned judgements through figuring out many of the key concerns and conflicting critiques approximately L2 writing examine and pedagogy. This ebook will support lecturers in making expert judgements approximately instructing writing within the ESL classroom.
To counteract a few of the debates, Casanave explores the various aspects of the arguments and gives examples of ways different lecturers have handled those matters. The booklet provides amateur and professional lecturers with thought-provoking concerns and inquiries to examine while opting for and reflecting on their lonesome educating suggestions and criteria.
Topics mentioned include:
contrastive rhetoric
product vs. process
fluency and accuracy
assessment of scholar work
politics and ideology.

Show description

Read Online or Download Controversies in Second Language Writing: Dilemmas and Decisions in Research and Instruction PDF

Best research books

Stimulated Recall Methodology in Second Language Research (Second Language Acquisition Research)

The method of introspection, and particularly of influenced remember, is gaining expanding reputation in moment language study. This e-book presents a "how-to" consultant for researchers contemplating utilizing this method, contextualized inside of a background of the strategy and a dialogue of its strengths and weaknesses.

Guide to e-Science: Next Generation Scientific Research and Discovery

The way clinical examine is performed is present process a chain of radical alterations, all over the world, because of the electronic revolution. even though, this “Science 2. zero” calls for a finished aiding cyber-infrastructure. This crucial guidebook on e-science provides real-world examples of practices and purposes, demonstrating how a variety of computational applied sciences and instruments should be hired to construct crucial infrastructures assisting next-generation clinical examine.

Research in Congenital Hypothyroidism

Systematic screening for congenital hypothyroidism within the baby was once brought a few 15 years in the past. the most target was once the prevention of psychological retardation as a result of thyroid hormone deficiency through the early months of existence. prior to now decade screening courses became regimen all through many of the industrialized global and plenty of questions when it comes to implementation, association and quality controls of such courses were mostly resolved.

Empiricist Research on Teaching: A Philosophical and Practical Critique of its Scientific Pretensions

This booklet indicates the unconventional thesis that there was a pervasive false impression in examine on instructing. In trying to be medical, researchers were empiricist. in addition, simply because they've got used a truly constrained form of empiricist strategy, their effects were in basic terms reasonably necessary.

Additional info for Controversies in Second Language Writing: Dilemmas and Decisions in Research and Instruction

Sample text

The famous eight-legged Chinese essay, they claimed, is no longer an influential genre (see also Cahill, 2003). Péry-Woodley (1990), too, focused her critiques of Kaplan’s (1966) groundbreaking article on the lack of attention to a number of important variables other than L1 rhetorical traditions that could influence students’ writing problems, some of which were pointed out by Kubota. Kaplan’s early views, stated Péry-Woodley (1990), were done “outside of any question of awareness of projected audience, writer-reader interaction, communication situation, text-type, or .

He further noted that these popular-opinion columns demonstrated the reader-responsible nature of Japanese writing (Hinds, 1987), in contrast to English (and modern Chinese), which he described as writerresponsible. In Japanese, he claimed, it is the responsibility of the reader to construct meaning, whereas in English the responsibility lies with the writer to ensure clarity. Japanese writers provide fewer landmarks and transition markers, leaving it to the reader to surmise the connections.

Therefore, if teachers and students wish to investigate how paragraph features in L2 and different L1s differ, it is important to look at samples in students’ L1s. In doing so, it is tempting to assume that the concept of “paragraph” is similar across languages. However, Régent (1985) found that even in another Western language the concept of “paragraph” was not shared. He compared 60 articles from medical journals in English and French and found that the French paragraphs were distinguished not by topic sentences that led readers through an argument but by loose collections of data.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.50 of 5 – based on 43 votes